Persuasion Analysis | by Hugh Rank | http://faculty.govst.edu/pa
Site Map

Introduction
Home / Index

Teachers Intro
Classroom Ideas
Useful Links

Teaching Aids (1 pg List)

Author
- Vita & Reviews
- Orwell awards
- Doublespeak awards
Site Map


Hugh Rank:Essays on Public Language

Brief Notes (Summary & 2006 Updates for these essays:
"The Teacher-Heal-Thyself Myth" (11 pp.)
"Watergate and the Language" (6 pp.)
"Liars in Public Places"
(3 pp.)
"Mr. Orwell, Mr. Schelesinger, and the Language." (6 pp.)
"Red Tape" (4 pp.)
"KIDVID: Child Molesters and Seducers" (2 pp.)
"Channel One, Misconceptions Three"
(6 pp.)
"Asking the Wrong Questions"
(about Channel One)

(6 pp.)
"Lies & Deceptions"
(24 pp.)

"Thinking About Thinking"
(4 pp.)
"Rent-a-Rhetorician"
(5 pp.)
Revisionists, Relativists, Ranke, and Rank


The bibliography and recommended book lists
of earlier versions of this site were replaced by links within the text to Amazon.com for easy access to their wide diversity of useful editorial reviews, reader reviews & suggested booklists.



Intensify/Downplay
Schema

Introduction
Background (of the schema)
The comprehensive taxonomy
Qualifications
(caveats about limits


Techniques
We intensify by...
Repetition
Association
Composition
We downplay by...
Omission
Diversion
Confusion

Benefit-Seeking
Behaviors


Protection
Relief
Prevention
Acquisition
Parental Roles vs Advertising
Benefit-Promising Behaviors

Intensify own "good"

Intensify others' "bad"
Downplay own "bad"
Downplay others' "good"


Counter-Propaganda
Axiom One:
"When they intensify, downplay."
Axiom Two: "When they downplay, intensify."

Advertising

The Pitch
An easy 1-2-3-4-5
"fingertip formula"
to analyze the basic structure of all ads.

1. HI: Attention-Getting

External Attention-Getters
-Television
--Early News
--Soap Operas
--Cartoons
--SundayMorning Talk Shows
--Sit-Coms
--Sports
--Award shows
--Ethnic programs
--Late Night Talk Shows
--Music Videos
-- Movies
--Game shows

-- Channel One
--Radio
--Online
--Print
--Outdoor
--Other
Internal Attention-Getters
Physical
Emotional
Cognitive
-Humor
-News
-Lists & Displays
-Advice (How to...)
-Lead-ins
-Questions
-Stories
-Demonstrations
-Breaking Rules

2. TRUST ME: Confidence-Building
-Expert
-Sincere
-Benevolent

-Presenters
-Words
-Nonverbals
-Brand Names
-Online Credibility
-Corporate Image

3. YOU NEED: Desire-Stimulating
-Product Centered
12 categories: Quality, Quantity, Beauty. Efficiency, Scarcity, Novelty,
Stability, Reliability, Simplicity, Utility, Rapidity, Safety,
-Audience-Centered
24 categories:
Food, Activity, Surroundings, Sex, Health, Security, Economy, Religion, Science. Best People. Most People, Average People, Neighborhood, Nation, Nature, Intimacy, Family, Friends, Groups, Esteem, Play, Generosity, Curiosity, Creativity, Success.

4. HURRY: Urgency-Stressing
-Urgency words
-Urgency nonverbals
-Hard Sell & Soft Sell
-Command and Conditioning propaganda


5. BUY: Response-Seeking
-Triggering words
-Telemarketing
-Direct Mail
-Online Response


Advertising: 1 pg PDF printouts

30-Second-Spot Quiz
Suggestions: How to...
Suggestions: Why...
Questions about Ads 200+
What's in it for me?
Ads in Class: T-F Quiz
Products Template (blank)


What's Wrong with Advertising?
Introduction

Obvious complaints:
-Intrusion
-Deception
-Offensive
-Personal Problems

Hidden harms:
-Materialism
-Environmental issues
-Social Justice
=====

Related Essays:
- Twitchell, Ad Cult USA
- Ruskin, Invasion of Privacy
- Seneca, on Simple Living
- Voluntary Moderation


The ABCs of TV Ads:
Ads are "units of persuasion"
Benefit-seeking by all
Claims are predictable
Disclosures are the "small print"
Emotional appeals are dominant
Feel Good ads are common
Getting attention is first job
Harmful effects can be indirect
Ignorance is dangerous
Jingles & Slogans repeated often
--top icons
--top jingles
--top slogans

Kids are a special target audience
--disposable income
--easily grouped
--gullible
--greedy

Lures (esp. TV) deliver audiences
Market Research has a major role
Negative ads common in politics
Omission of disadvantages
Patterns of ads are predictable
Questioning ads is best way
Response is the goal of ads
Scare and sell ads stimulate fears
Trust is important
Urgency is common
Visuals imply, implicitly suggest
Web ads are like TV ads
X-rated ads not on Channel One
--Disclaimer re: Channel One
Your ... limits, priorities, values
Zipping and zapping won't work
-- New Techniques & Venues

Summary / Review


A Companion to Composition: Welcome

Intro: College & AP Students
Introduction for Teachers
"Thinking About Thinking"

- Newman

10 Rhetorical Concepts useful
to analyze persuasion of TV ads;
to compose your own writings:
Purpose
-Writer's purpose
-Ad's purpose
-Audience's purpose
-Hidden purpose

Audience
-Target audience
-Audience knowledge
-Audience feelings
-Feedback

Limits
-Space limits
-Time limits
-Technical limits
-Legal limits

Structure
-Overall structure
-Parts
-Emphasis
-Coherence

Attention
-Context
-Strategies
-Physical
-Emotional

Confidence

-Image
-Words & nonverbals
-Authorities
-Credentials

Explicit

-Explicit claims
-Key words
-Intensifiers
-Qualifiers

Implicit

-Suggestions
-Connotations
-Figures of speech
-Nonverbals

Urgency & Response
-Urgency, use
-Urgency, appropriateness
-Specific response
-Delayed response

Omissions

-Assumptions
-Relevant omissions
-Downplay techniques
-Disclosures


Political Rhetoric
Introduction

Election Rhetoric

Images & Issues
and a
Checklist

Questions you can ask, 200+
Why analyze political language?

Common Complaints
About Political Language

-Always arguing -Same old stuff -Boring -Lies -Negative ads
-Promises -Regulations
-Red Tape


Not-So-Great
Expectations

Introduction
2004 Election Rhetoric

Overview (1pg)
Generalizations
George Lakoff's
"Moral Politics"
Model Citizens & Demons
Rank's 1 pg Adaptation of Lakoff's Family Models

Current Examples of Political Language:
War Words 2003-2006:

Politics & War
"War" on Terrorism?
Terrorism & Violence
The Seven Deadly Spins
Bush Bashing?
Plausible Deniability
Presidential Campaign Stories

God-on-Our-Side
Moral Superiority
, "Values"
Self-Righteousness
Whistleblowers
Euphemisms:
Civilian Contractors
Atrocity Pictures: Abu Ghraib. Iraq Prison,2004
(nonverbals, images)
Revisionists, Relativism, Ranke, and Rank

DefinitionsTerri Schiavo Case
Jimmy Carter, (2005)
"This isn't the real America"


The Pep Talk:
Cause Group Rhetoric


1. Threat
Problem-makers

Warnings
Namecalling
Horror stories
Atrocity Pictures
Predictable Fears
--Death & Destruction
--Invasion
--Restriction
--Dominance
--Inequality
--Chaos

2. Bonding
Themes:
Unity
Loyalty
Pride

Actions, bonding
Group
Leader

3. Cause
Self-image benefits
Conflicts
God-on-Our Side
Moral superiority
Ethical issues

4. Response
Specific actions
Triggering words

Summary (1 page)


War Propaganda